Category: Blog

Home  ›  Blog  ›  Page 7

AQ: Motor die-cast rotor non-grain-oriented VS grain-oriented

If the material is non-grain-oriented, the path of least resistance for the magnetic flux varies widely from point to point across the sheet: in one place it may go left-to-right across the sheet surface, in another top-to-bottom, and in still another through the sheet. Other points may be anywhere and everywhere in between.

If the material is grain-oriented, the material is aligned such that there is a significant reduction in the energy requirement for passing flux in one direction relative to any other.

Most machines work best with a uniform flux distribution at all points of the airgap surface: this is achieved by stacking both stator and rotor using non-grain-oriented laminations in any arrangement. However, for a grain-oriented material, each lamination has to be rotated by some angle with respect to the one above and below it in the stack (think of it like a spiral staircase).

Regardless of how the winding is made for the rotor (form wound, bar and ring, or die-cast), it is the STACKING process for the core steel that affects grain orientation.

As to skewing BOTH stator and rotor … why? It is a more costly and complex manufacturing process to produce a skewed core vs an unskewed one, regardless whether the skew is in the rotor or stator. Once the skew is begun, there is no real cost difference between a full slot skew and a fractional slot skew.

If you really want to skew both, though – opt for a half-slot skew in one direction in the rotor, and a half-slot skew in the opposite direction for the stator. Note that this means there is only ONE way to assemble rotor and stator together – with the skews opposing. (With the full slot skew on either rotor or stator and an unskewed opposite piece, the rotor can be inserted from either end of the stator with the same effect.)

AQ: Sensorless motor control with TI and Microchip

Question:
I need to learn about the sensorless control of permanent magnet AC (PMAC) motors. Can you recommend a tutorial and/or open source code for the sensorless motor control using the
a) TI TMS320 series processor, or
b) Microchip dsPIC33EP128 series processor?

Answer:
I have used Microchip and TMS320 to develop VFD. They provide you with a demo kit, PCB and a motor. It take me half a day to get the demo PCB running with my PMSM. Then I copy their design to my own.

The Microchip solution provides you with demo code. I used that before, but it require quite a bit of C programming, and motor tuning take even longer. The demo code and application note are no where near the performance of the Ti solution (I do not work for Ti -so I am not advertising). I take me a week to get my motor spinning with the demo kit from Microchip.

Then there are the International Rectifier solution that is available from many years. The IR sensorless motion control solution have implemented a FOC motor control in FPGA. So you don’t need to write code for motor control. In the chip, it also has a 8051 cpu. You write the program in C; 1 page of code will get a washing machine working. It takes me 1 day to get a PMSM motor running with this solution.

I will use the TI solution for high end motor control – such as a US$40,000 dollar, 100HP direct drive PCP used in the oil field.
I will use the IR solution for a water pump, washing machine – things that is a few kw.
I will use the microchip for solution for toys, because Microchip is so much fun to play with.

AQ: Die-cast rotor design

The method of creating a die-cast rotor is as follows:

1. An assembly of steel laminations (which may or may not be grain-oriented) containing the openings for both rotor bars and ventilation (as required) is made and clamped together to form a cylindrical iron core.
2. The assembly is inserted into a mold, which has space both above and below the core for the end (shorting) ring assembly.
3. The molten conductor material (aluminum or copper, usually) is injected into the mold and allowed to flow through the bar openings. It also fills the end ring spaces.
4. The entire assembly is allowed to cool so that the conductor solidifies.
5. The “cast” core is then shrunk onto a steel shaft.

Now we have a “cast” rotor assembly, ready for bearings and mounting into machine.

AQ: ACS800-104-0105-3 (ABB VFD Drives)

Question:
I have a problem with ABB ACS800-104-0105-3 drive model, the output current reading on the VFD is always double the reading of the clamp ampere(i.e. drive reading= 40 A, clamp ampere reading=20 A), what is the procedure that i can follow to detect the cause of this error?

Answer:
I don’t know about ABB drives, but hope this thing will help you.
1. The variable frequency drive may have problem with current sensor, just replace with another drive for comparison.
2. Make sure you use, true RMS type clamp meter.
3. If there is leakage current (through cable insulation and air) between each phase. This normally because of the cable insulation already degraded. Add output reactor and replace the cable with suitable insulation can fix this kind of problem.
4. If there is leakage current between this VFD drive and the other drives, that both motor cable is quiet long and run in parallel together.

To Collect more data and get more idea, you can do this:
1. Clamp all the 3 phase motor cable together using clamp. The reading will show you the leakage current. Normally about 10% of motor rated current at full load.
2. Check the current on each phase, and see if the current is balance for each phase.
3. Run the variable frequency drive without the motor cable, check the current reading and clamp meter.
4. Run the AC drive with the motor cable but without the motor, check again the reading and clamp meter.
5. Run the drive with motor, check if any oscillation in motor current.
6. Check current input to the AC drive inverter.
7. Turn of the other drive (if the motor cable run parallel together with other VFDs), and see if any change in current.

AQ: Electric motor rotor and stator

When building a traditional electric machine (motor or generator), the idea is to distribute the flux very evenly over both the rotor and stator surfaces where they contact the air gap. This means using either grain-oriented steels and rotating each lamination slightly from the previous one to provide a relatively even flux path, or using a non-grain-oriented steel and having the flux distribute on its own.

Grain-oriented steels are good for lowering magnetizing flux – provided the grain in each lamination is aligned in the same direction. This can also help with reducing stray loss and eddy loss (flux that travels parallel to the shaft and does no useful “work”).

Most electrical steels used in stator and rotor construction also have an insulating coating applied; some of these are organic materials and some are inorganic (solvent-based) materials. The choice is typically made based on a combination of temperature gradient and local environmental laws. The inorganic (solvent) materials can generally withstand higher temperatures but are far less eco-friendly in the manufacture of the coating material or in the curing of the coating after it is applied.

Since most coatings are applied after the rolling-to-thickness process, these are usually cold-rolled steels. The use of cold- vs hot-rolled material can also be based on tooth / slot geometry: for very narrow teeth that require “post processing” for a coating, hot rolled is often used because the material will retain its geometry better through the temperatures used to cure the coating.

Skewing is the relationship between a rotor “turn” and a stator “turn”. Each manufacturer is different; and different machines (synchronous, induction, Permanent magnet, direct current) approach it differently. For example – it is usually easier to skew the stator laminations of an AC machine, because the insertion of the coils is easier. For a DC machine, skewing of the rotor is preferred for the same reason. The amount of skew is typically one slot pitch … which means that one end of the machine has the slot centerline aligned with the opposite end’s tooth centerline.

Grain orientation only applies to the lamination steels … not the conductor materials.

Energy efficient bearing is really a misnomer. However, they can be thought of as those that are sized to have relatively low friction coefficients and therefore low thermal losses (so that you don’t have to use extra energy to cool the lubricant). In the bigger picture, they would also use a lubricant that is less energy-intensive to produce and / or require less replacement.

AQ: Figure out variable speed drives failures

If there is frequent current-limitation or overcurrent alarm during the variable speed drive running, we should check the loads and inverter IGBT module is normal or not, if its good, then the failure is the Hall magnetic compensation current sensor damaged on the control circuit of the variable speed drive. Hall magnetic compensation current sensor is a device to measure the current value of sinusoidal and non-sinusoidal periodic, which can truly reflect the real current waveform, to provide a control and protection signal to the variable speed drive. Generally, this device in variable frequency drive mostly is Swiss company LEM LA series components, LA Series Hall current sensor magnetic compensation can be divided into three and five terminals, for different variable speed drives capacity, the Hall current sensor magnetic compensation also is difference.

Electronic components are very sensitive to static electricity, it will cause electronic components soft breakdown and then cause the circuit board cannot work. So we should be careful when we replace the circuit board, and ensure wearing grounding wrist strap before working, make sure the strap ground directly and human body is at zero potential, in order to prevent body’s electrostatic damage to the circuit board. If there is no grounding wrist strap, we should touch the variable speed drive metal cabinet before replacing the circuit board, to ease static electricity through the variable frequency drive enclosure.

AQ: Energy Efficient Motor VS Standard motor

This is a very simplified comparison for a very complex issue. Every motor manufacturer is somewhat different in their approach, and there are literally thousands of design details in each machine that can be accommodated as the designer balances efficiency VS performance VS cost VS reliability VS safety VS manufacturability.

To generalize a bit, take a look at the following list. Not everything is there (not by a long shot!) but there should be enough to give you a reasonable overview. Note that some items are “design” related, while others are “operation” related.

1. Use a lower loss material for both stator and rotor laminations.
2. Use a larger copper cross-section for the same power rating.
3. Skew rotor winding with respect to stator winding.
4. Use more magnetic material (diameter, length, or both) to reduce flux densities.
5. Effectively size the machine for a somewhat higher rating than nameplate (because the typical peak of the efficiency curve occurs somewhere between 70 and 85 percent “rated” load).
6. Operate the machine at reduced temperatures and/or increase coolant flow.
7. Limit input frequency and/or voltage variation to tighter tolerance (note that this is a specification approach, not a manufacturing approach).
8. Better bearings / lubrication to reduce friction loss.
9. More care taken with internal geometry – i.e. closed slots, large air gaps, generous tooth dimensions, smooth surfaces, etc – to reduce windage.

AQ: AC drive faults analysis

It will cause a series problems during AC drive operation in various environmental conditions, take an example as: when failure occurs, AC drives protective function is activated, and the AC drive tripped immediately, the electric motor stop slowly, the red LED alarm indication turns on, the display panel shows alarm message code or fault content. Then we can analyze the variable frequency AC drive fault reasons base on the display information, if it is soft failures, we can cut of the AC drive and reset it. If the drive still not works, we need to check it manually or automatic initialization, and input the parameter values after the initialization finished. In this way, the AC drive can work if the failure is not critical. If the AC drive still can’t work after above detection, then we need to check the variable frequency drive damaged parts according to the fault phenomena, to replace components or circuit boards. Troubleshooting should follow the drives failure sequence. Like:

(1) Fault code 36, its main power failure, then the three-phase rectifier bridge modules may be breakdown shorted or opened.

(2) Fault code 14, its ground failure, check the motor windings and insulation with megger to see if it’s damaged or not.

(3) Fault code 37, its the inverter failure, the IGBT module may short-circuit breakdown. If the IGBT module short circuit, the main circuit fuse will burnout too. When a phase gate damaged, the variable frequency AC drive will appear overcurrent phenomenon, then it’s time to check the IGBT modules.

AQ: Variable frequency drive key functions

Soft Starter, Auto Transformer, Electrolyte, series resistance – wound rotor- etc,). The starting factor of VFD drive is usually 1 up to 1.2 with respect to the rated load current while for Direct On line about 5-6.

Moreover and as you know the variable frequency drive can control the speed of the AC motors in accordance to the formula N=120f/P rpm
where f = the supply frequency and P = number of the Poles.
According to this formula, Motor Speed can be changed either by changing/control the frequency or by changing the number of Poles of the Motor by which step changed in the RPM will be given, while the former gives continuous variable speed as per application demand.

However, as per newly developed power Semi Conductor IGCT based on PWM VFD became the most smart, effective and efficient control device in Industries since is associated also with protective and monitoring means.

From my experience, I know that variable frequency drive plays around with the frequency which the motor operates. It starts at low speed and varies the frequency to attain maximum speed. This reduces the high starting torque usually experienced when motors are started on DOL, Star/Delta etc. When you are driving delicate materials through your conveyors or pumping liquid through pipes etc., VFD plays a useful role. It reduces hammering in pipes usually experienced when using DOL. In large hotel application, variable frequency drive could be used with pressure switches to regulate water flow and reduce hammering when guests are showing. The volume of water required will determine the speed at which the motor runs through VFD control. However, very large KW motors at high voltage level are usually started DOL due to the cost of ac drive but that is when one has enough (power) capacity otherwise it will impact on other users in the network.

AQ: Control Servo motor with a variable frequency drive

Looking at those AC drives they recommend an Induction motor. A servo motor with permanent magnets which is not quite an induction motor. So, if a servo with permanent magnets can be used instead an induction with these kinds of AC drives.

Actually, the term “Servo” makes a reference about “feedback”, it means, whether we need a control loop, we are talking in terms about Servo, in this case, we have, or we know, the “feedback” by an encoder. Typical variable frequency drive doesn’t have a input for an encoder, so, if you want to control a Servo Motor with a VFD, you can move the motor, but you can’t control it.

A servo motor can be an induction servo, a brushless servo, a reluctance servo a dc servo – each of these can be either linear or rotary and can come with a variety of feedback such as tachometer, resolver of various pole counts, incremental or absolute encoders discreet or serial interface with different bus options, laser feedback, halls etc.

Then you come to the term variable frequency drive. Brushless servo amplifiers are also vfds. Do standard inverters have proper control of induction, and brushless motors. Some allow for a software switch, some allow for a firmware download, some don’t. Will inverters accept feedback – some have it built in, most that allow it do so by option cards, many do not.

Normal input in a variable frequency drive is, digital to start or stop, and we could have an analogic input to control by potentiometer.

Using AC Drives for the servo application is quite possible, provided the application is less demanding in critical positioning purpose.
There are number of makes that showcases pinpoint positioning of motor shaft being driven by AC Drives like Hitachi SJ700 / Emerson Uni drive SP / Danfoss FC etc.

Its beneficial to opt for the AC Drives as it supports SLVC [ VFD gives almost servo-like torque at low rpms if you give it encoder feedback ], multiple motors can be accessed, torque requirement can be met if required, power dips can be sustained using VFD’s.